Some of the cheapest rent on the BART map sits next to a station BART plans to close. A UCSF nurse commute from Pittsburg, Concord, or Vallejo saves thousands a year on rent. On November 3, Bay Area voters decide whether BART keeps running at full strength. I ranked these towns again by what you keep after taxes and rent, and by which commutes still work if the transit measure fails.
Staff RN · Map My Pay Co-Founder · October 2026
Last week, my guide to getting hired at UCSF ranked the towns a nurse could rent in by how much of the paycheck is left after rent. Pittsburg and Vallejo came out near the top of that list. Then I read BART's backup plan. Both Pittsburg stations are on it.
The Connect Bay Area measure is on the November 3 ballot. It adds a half-cent sales tax in Alameda, Contra Costa, San Mateo, and Santa Clara counties and a full cent in San Francisco for 14 years. That raises about $980 million a year, according to the Eno Center for Transportation. If it passes, BART skips the cuts. If it fails, the first ones start on January 11.
So I scored each town on two things. The first is what a nurse keeps after taxes and rent. The second is whether the UCSF nurse commute still works under both outcomes. Two groups fall outside that test, because the vote does not decide their commute. A Vallejo nurse on the ferry is limited by the boat schedule instead. A nurse who drives feels the vote through bridge traffic.
| At a glance | |
|---|---|
| Vote | November 3, 2026 (regional measure, plus Prop H in San Francisco) |
| First BART cuts if it fails | January 11, 2027 (BART's planning date) |
| Trains | Every 30 minutes on three all-day lines |
| Closing time | 9 p.m., seven days a week |
| Weekend start | 8 a.m. on Saturday and Sunday |
| Stations closed | 10 in January, 15 by July 2027 |
| Fares | Up 30% in January, 50% by July |
| Most kept after rent | Vallejo, $98,614 a year |
| Steadiest commute | Daly City, $92,350 a year |
The bottom line: If you work at UCSF and want rent savings that hold up after the vote, look first at Daly City, Concord, and the Yellow-line parts of Oakland. Pittsburg and Orinda save a little more on rent today, but their stations are on BART's closure lists. Vallejo keeps the most and sits outside BART's plan, though its ferry only fits weekday shifts. If you drive, the vote still reaches you. San Francisco's mayor says peak Bay Bridge traffic would more than double if both transit measures fail.
What BART's backup plan does to a UCSF nurse commute
BART's board approved a backup plan in February for the case where the measure fails. The details are in the presentation staff gave the board. The plan comes in two rounds, and BART only moves to the second if it decides the system can run safely at that level.
The January Cuts
BART's planning timeline puts the first cuts on January 11, 2027. Train hours drop 63%. The Yellow, Blue, and Orange lines run all day with two trains an hour, so a missed train means a 30-minute wait. The Red and Green lines run only at rush hour in the busy direction. That means toward San Francisco in the morning and away from it in the evening.
Every station closes at 9 p.m., seven days a week, and weekend trains start at 8 a.m. Fares and parking go up 30%. Ten stations close: Castro Valley, North Concord/Martinez, Oakland Airport, Orinda, Pittsburg Center, San Bruno, South Hayward, South San Francisco, Warm Springs, and West Dublin/Pleasanton. BART expects the share of trips that need a transfer to rise from 7% to 22%.
The July Cuts
If BART moves to the second round in July 2027, train hours fall 70% below today and 15 stations close. The Yellow line ends at Concord, which closes Pittsburg/Bay Point and Antioch. The Blue line stops, and the Orange line ends at Bay Fair. Stations south of Daly City close, though trains still run to SFO. By then, fares sit 50% above today.
Muni and the Last Mile
San Francisco voters also decide Prop H. It is a 15-year parcel tax that would raise about $184 million a year for Muni, Mission Local reports. Without it, Muni says it could cut service on some routes by up to 50%, drop less-used lines, and run less at night. I could not find a published list of the routes Muni would cut, so the bus and train lines to Parnassus and Mission Bay can't be checked yet.
Look up rent and take-home for any town on your route before you sign. Map My Pay covers more than 21,000 U.S. cities.
Browse cities in the app →A UCSF nurse commute against a 9 p.m. close
Most of the service BART would keep lines up with a 9-to-5 workday. A 12-hour shift runs into the cuts at both ends of the day. Weekends get hit the hardest.
| Shift | Weekdays if the measure fails | Weekends if the measure fails |
|---|---|---|
| Day shift, 7 a.m. to 7:30 p.m. | The ride home has to beat the 9 p.m. close, with trains every 30 minutes | The first train comes at 8 a.m., an hour after the shift starts |
| Night shift, 7 p.m. to 7:30 a.m. | Works both ways | The ride home waits for the 8 a.m. first train |
Day Shifts
If your day shift ends around 7:30 p.m., you have about 90 minutes to give report, get to BART, and ride home before the 9 p.m. close. With trains every 30 minutes, one late discharge can cost you the train you planned on. BART has not said when the last trains would leave under a 9 p.m. close. Plan for an earlier cutoff than the clock suggests.
Nurses in Richmond and El Cerrito have a second problem. The Red line, their direct ride from San Francisco, would run only at rush hour. After the evening rush, the ride home means changing trains in Oakland.
Weekend Shifts
BART already opens at 8 a.m. on Sundays, and today Saturday trains start at 6 a.m. The plan moves Saturday to 8 a.m. too. A night shift that ends at 7:30 a.m. on a weekend means waiting for the first train and then up to 30 minutes for the next one. A weekend day shift that starts at 7 a.m. can't use BART to get there at all.
UCSF Shuttles
UCSF runs its own shuttles, and they do not depend on Muni or Prop H. The three routes that link BART to the campuses run on weekdays only:
On weekdays, your last mile to either campus survives even if Prop H fails. On weekends, that last mile runs on Muni alone, on the same two days BART would open late.
Where a UCSF nurse should live under both outcomes
I scored each town on money kept after taxes and rent and on a ride to UCSF that holds up whether the measure passes or fails. The money side turned out closer than I expected. From Vallejo down to Daly City, the yearly amount kept differs by only $6,264. The train ends up deciding more than the rent does.
Sponsored · Map My Pay earns a commission if you use the SoFi link below.
Take-home pay only tells part of the story if some of every check goes to student loans. Start with the free check: see if your hospital counts for Public Service Loan Forgiveness on studentaid.gov. Many nonprofit and public hospitals do, and refinancing federal loans into a private loan ends that option for good.
If PSLF is not your plan, or your loans are already private, Map My Pay partners with SoFi at Work. My wife and I have used SoFi ourselves. We cosigned our daughter's college loans with them and borrowed from them when we bought our house. Their rates were the best we found, and they are still some of the best I see. Our readers get member rate discounts on student loan refinancing, and checking your rate won't affect your credit score. Check your SoFi member rate →
Daly City
A UCSF nurse who rents in Daly City keeps $92,350 a year after taxes and rent. That is $14,064 more than in San Francisco, or about $1,172 a month. Daly City keeps a direct Yellow-line ride into the city in both rounds of cuts, plus the Blue line in January. There is no bridge to cross.
If you work at Parnassus, the Pink shuttle leaves from the Colma park-and-ride lot, just south of Daly City. The current schedule leaves Colma between 5:15 and 8:50 a.m. and leaves Parnassus between 3:30 and 8:20 p.m. Colma's BART station sits in the stretch south of Daly City that BART plans to close in July, but the shuttle runs from the parking lot, so driving there still works.
Concord
Concord keeps $94,162 a year, $15,876 more than San Francisco. Rent runs $56 a month more than in Pittsburg, or $672 a year. In exchange, you get a station that stays on the Yellow line in both rounds.
On today's map, Concord sits two stops from Pittsburg/Bay Point, with North Concord/Martinez in between. North Concord closes in January, which leaves Concord one stop from Pittsburg/Bay Point. In July, Concord becomes the end of the line. If you rent near North Concord, plan on driving to Concord station.
Oakland on the Yellow Line
Oakland keeps $93,934 a year, $15,648 more than San Francisco. In Oakland, the station you use decides more than in any other town on this list. West Oakland, 12th Street, 19th Street, MacArthur, and Rockridge sit on the Yellow line and keep a direct ride in both rounds.
Lake Merritt, Fruitvale, and Coliseum lose their direct ride to San Francisco when the Blue line ends in July, which leaves the Orange line and a transfer. Oakland already came out ahead of San Francisco in my comparison of California hospital pay after rent. The figure here uses Oakland's citywide average rent, so an apartment in Rockridge can cost more than the average.
Vallejo
Vallejo keeps the most, $98,614 a year, or $20,328 more than San Francisco. Its ferry is not part of BART's plan, and the ferry system gets only 0.7% of the measure's money, according to SPUR. I found no published ferry cuts tied to the vote.
The ferry schedule is the limit. On weekdays, the first boat reaches San Francisco at 6:30 a.m., and the last one back leaves at 8:10 p.m. On weekends, the first boat does not arrive until 10:15 a.m. The boat lands at the Ferry Building, so you still need Muni for the last stretch, and a 6:30 a.m. arrival leaves little room before a 7 a.m. start.
The fare is $10 each way. On three 12-hour shifts a week, that comes to about $3,120 a year. Vallejo still ends up about $17,208 ahead of San Francisco.
El Cerrito and Richmond
Richmond keeps $94,882 and El Cerrito keeps $94,426, about $16,000 more than San Francisco in both towns. Their stations stay open in both rounds. Under the plan, the Red line runs only at rush hour. The Orange line still runs all day, but it does not cross the bay, so outside rush hour you change trains in Oakland. For a nurse heading home after a 7:30 p.m. shift change, that transfer lands close to the 9 p.m. close.
Pittsburg and Orinda
These two save a bit more on rent than Concord or Oakland, and they carry the most risk. Orinda keeps $95,530 a year, but its station closes in January, so you would drive to Lafayette or Rockridge. Pittsburg keeps $94,834. Pittsburg Center closes in January, and Pittsburg/Bay Point closes in July when the Yellow line ends at Concord. A Pittsburg renter could end up driving to Concord station anyway, while saving only $56 a month on rent.
Drivers
If you drive, the vote reaches you through traffic. San Francisco Mayor Daniel Lurie said peak Bay Bridge traffic would more than double if both transit measures fail. Outside San Francisco itself, Daly City is the only town on this list where you never cross a bridge to get to work.
What each town keeps after rent
The table holds pay steady at the San Francisco RN median, because the job is at UCSF wherever you live. That median is $188,020 a year, which comes to $124,246 after federal and California taxes. Each town's yearly rent comes off that same number. Switching employers would change the pay itself, and my comparison of UC hospital pay puts the choice of campus alone at five figures a year.
| Town | Rent a month | Kept a year | More than SF | If the measure fails |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vallejo, CA | $2,136 | $98,614 | +$20,328 | Ferry, no published cuts, weekday schedule |
| Orinda, CA | $2,393 | $95,530 | +$17,244 | Station closes in January |
| Richmond, CA | $2,447 | $94,882 | +$16,596 | Station stays, transfer outside rush hour |
| Pittsburg, CA | $2,451 | $94,834 | +$16,548 | Pittsburg Center closes in January, Pittsburg/Bay Point in July |
| El Cerrito, CA | $2,485 | $94,426 | +$16,140 | Stations stay, transfer outside rush hour |
| Concord, CA | $2,507 | $94,162 | +$15,876 | Direct Yellow-line ride, end of the line by July |
| Oakland, CA | $2,526 | $93,934 | +$15,648 | Direct on Yellow-line stations, transfer from East Oakland by July |
| Daly City, CA | $2,658 | $92,350 | +$14,064 | Direct Yellow-line ride in both rounds, no bridge |
| San Francisco, CA | $3,830 | $78,286 | baseline | Depends on Muni and Prop H |
Source: Map My Pay city database, May 2026 export (BLS May 2024 wages, 2026 tax engine). Pay is held at the San Francisco RN median net of $124,246 in every town. Rent is each city's average and does not include BART or ferry fares. These figures come from a different export than my UCSF hiring guide, so they will not match it exactly. Green marks the steadiest commute; red marks towns with stations on BART's closure lists.
Concord's rent runs $56 a month more than Pittsburg's. Concord stays on the Yellow line in both rounds of cuts. Both Pittsburg stations are on BART's closure lists.
See what UCSF and other Bay Area hospitals pay after taxes in the Map My Pay salary tool.
Check hospital pay →Lease timing around November 3
A lease is the one part of this you control before the vote. If you are signing one this fall, three dates are worth knowing:
If a landlord in Pittsburg or Orinda offers you a 12-month lease before the vote, ask about a shorter term, even at a higher rent. If the measure passes, BART skips the January cuts and the ranking in my UCSF guide still holds. If it fails, a shorter lease gives you room to move before July, when the second round of closures could start.
Why trust this breakdown: I'm a staff RN, and I pulled these numbers myself from BART's board presentation, SF Bay Ferry's posted schedule, UCSF's shuttle pages, and the Map My Pay city database. Every dollar figure traces back to a numbered column in our data, and nobody paid to be on this list.
For a UCSF nurse, some of the cheapest rent on the BART map sits next to stations BART plans to close. Daly City, Concord, and the Yellow-line parts of Oakland cost between $56 and $207 a month more in rent than Pittsburg. In return, they keep a direct ride to San Francisco whether the measure passes or fails. One stop is worth $56 a month.
See the rent and take-home for your own BART stop in the Map My Pay city browser.
Compare your town →This article is for general information and is not financial, tax, or legal advice. Take-home figures are estimates from the Map My Pay city database (May 2026 export, BLS May 2024 wages, 2026 tax engine), holding pay at the San Francisco RN median and subtracting each city's average rent. BART's plan, Muni's plans, and transit schedules can change before or after the November 3 vote.
Sources: BART Board Workshop presentation, February 12, 2026 (bart.gov). NBC Bay Area / Bay City News, "BART board OKs contingency plan," February 27, 2026. Eno Center for Transportation, "Transportation at the Ballot Box 2026: Connect Bay Area Transit," September 2026. Mission Local, "S.F. economy will take a hit if Muni measure fails," September 16, 2026. SPUR, "Connect Bay Area Act Authorizes a Regional Tax Measure to Save Transit," October 22, 2025. ABC7 San Francisco, "Report claims Bay Area commuters face significantly longer drives if transit funding fails," September 2026. San Francisco Bay Ferry, Vallejo route schedule effective March 9, 2026, and fares effective July 1, 2026. UCSF Campus Life Services, Red and Pink shuttle schedules. Map My Pay city database.
